Tier 1 re-checks: options for RedBird
Nov 19, 2026
We recommend re-checking an approved Tier 1 bidder only when something changes, not on a yearly cycle. This is how Christie's works, and it matches how UK rules, and EU rules from July 2027, ask for existing customers to be reviewed. No US rule asks an auction platform for a yearly re-check.
The decision
Once a bidder has Tier 1 approval, when do we check them again? Approval is given once, as agreed on 18 Nov, so this is the safety net behind it.
A · Only when something changes. A set list of events triggers a re-check.
B · Every year. Every Tier 1 bidder confirms their details once a year.
What you told us
On 18 Nov you asked whether "there should be an annual check or confirmation process", for example to "certify, like, your credit score hasn't changed", in case a bidder has a "decline in their net worth".
We said we would research periodic re-checks. This doc is that research.
How others do it
Houses re-check on events: a bidder who wants to spend more, has not bought for a while, or bids above their line. None of the house terms we read sets a yearly re-check of approved bidders.
| House | When they check again |
|---|---|
| Christie's (New York conditions, Apr 2025) | A returning bidder who has not bought "within the last two years", or wants to spend more than before, must contact the house first. Christie's "may at our option ask you for current identification, a financial reference, or a deposit" |
| Sotheby's | ID at account opening. Extra checks for some sales and lots: "Some auctions and lots require additional financial verification such as a bank reference." May check the source of funds on payment. No yearly re-check described |
| Heritage | A credit check to bid above an established line; may ask a deposit of up to 25% |
| Propstore (London) | Extra checks on orders of EUR 10,000 or more |
What the rules say
For your legal team to confirm. No US rule today asks a memorabilia auction platform to re-check bidders on a calendar. Where re-checks are law, in the UK now and the EU from July 2027, they are risk-based and triggered when a customer's circumstances change, not a flat yearly cycle for everyone.
| Rule | Status | What it says about re-checks |
|---|---|---|
| FinCEN rulemaking for dealers in antiquities (US) | Withdrawn on 16 Apr 2025, per Treasury's regulatory agenda in the Federal Register | No rule was ever made |
| Art Market Integrity Act, S.2400 (US) | A bill introduced in the Senate on 23 Jul 2025 and referred to committee; no later action in what we read | Would bring "a person engaged in the trade in works of art" under US anti-money-laundering law, with small-volume sellers exempt. Its "work of art" list covers paintings, sculptures, prints, drawings, photographs and similar; film props are not on it. Sets no review cycle |
| OFAC Framework for Compliance Commitments (US sanctions) | Published guidance | Asks for "a risk-based approach to sanctions compliance". Screening not updated for list changes is named as a cause of violations; programmes "should be capable of adjusting rapidly to changes published by OFAC" |
| UK Money Laundering Regulations 2017, regulation 27 | In force | Art market participants check customers on art trades of £10,000 or more. Existing customers are checked again "at other appropriate times ... on a risk based approach", and when their circumstances change |
| EU Anti-Money Laundering Regulation 2024/1624 (official EU text) | Applies from 10 Jul 2027 | Covers traders in cultural goods, including auction houses, on trades of EUR 10,000 or more. Customer information is reviewed at intervals set by risk, at most every year for higher-risk customers and every five years for all others, and also when a customer's circumstances change |
Points for your legal team:
Confirm that no US anti-money-laundering duty applies to RedBird's sales today.
Whether film props could count as "works of art" under S.2400 if it passes, or as "cultural goods" under the EU rules.
Any UK or EU exposure if RedBird sells there. HMRC's guidance page states the UK threshold as 10,000 euros, while the current regulation says £10,000.
Options compared
A checks a bidder at the moment their risk changes; B checks everyone on a date, whether or not anything changed.
| A · Only when something changes (recommended) | B · Every year | |
|---|---|---|
| Active Tier 1 buyers | Rarely asked for anything | Asked every year |
| Your "decline in their net worth" case | Caught when they ask for a higher line than past spend, or a payment fails | Caught only at the next yearly date |
| Changes between checks | Caught when they happen | Missed until the next cycle |
| Fit with UK and EU rules | Matches their risk-based, change-of-circumstances shape | Stricter than the UK rule asks; the EU sets a yearly review only for higher-risk customers |
| Operations | Needs a clear, written trigger list | Simple to explain; a yearly paperwork round for your team and your top bidders |
Our recommendation and why
We recommend A. An approved Tier 1 bidder is re-checked when any of these happens:
A payment fails or is charged back.
They add a new card, or their card expires.
A sanctions-list match. We re-screen all Tier 1 bidders whenever the sanctions lists change, not only at these events.
A new name, address or country.
They ask for a bidding line above what they have spent before.
Two years without a purchase.
Your team asks for a re-check, at any time.
Why:
It is how Christie's works. Triggers 5 and 6 are Christie's own: no purchase in two years, or a wish to spend more than before.
It catches your net worth case at the right moment. Risk changes when someone asks for more, or stops paying. A calendar date can miss both.
It matches the rules where they exist. UK and EU rules ask for reviews on risk and on changed circumstances. OFAC expects screening kept current with list changes, hence trigger 3.
Two years without a purchase, not without bidding. A purchase is easy to verify and matches Christie's rule.
One point for your legal team: if RedBird ever became a covered trader under the EU rules, its higher-risk Tier 1 bidders would need a review at least once a year. We would add that cycle for them then.
What your auction side may push back on, and our answer:
"Two years is long for a top bidder." Trigger 5 catches anyone who steps up before then.
"Top clients hate paperwork." Under A, most active Tier 1 buyers are never asked.
"We want discretion." Trigger 7 gives your team a re-check at any time, as Christie's keeps "at our option".
What we take on and what we need from you
Povio takes on:
The seven triggers built into the product, each starting a re-check automatically.
A clear message on the bidder's account when a re-check is due ("confirm your card to keep bidding in Tier 1 sales").
Re-screening all Tier 1 bidders against the sanctions lists whenever the lists change.
A record of every re-check: date, trigger and outcome.
We need from you:
Confirm the trigger list, and "two years without a purchase" rather than without bidding.
Your legal team confirms the US position and any UK or EU exposure (the three points above).
How we'll measure it
We report these monthly:
Re-checks started, by trigger.
Time from a re-check starting to clearing.
Tier 1 bidders lost at a re-check.
Payment failures among Tier 1 winners.
Sources
Christie's, Conditions of Sale, New York (1 Apr 2025), section B.2, read 19 Nov 2026
Sotheby's, Guide for Buyers (updated 6 Nov 2026), read 19 Nov 2026
Heritage, Terms and Conditions of Auction, read 16 Nov 2026
Propstore, Terms and Conditions, read 16 Nov 2026
Federal Register, Treasury Semiannual Regulatory Agenda, FR Doc. 2025-18332, FinCEN RIN 1506-AB50, read 19 Nov 2026
Congress.gov, S.2400, Art Market Integrity Act, as introduced, read 19 Nov 2026
OFAC, A Framework for OFAC Compliance Commitments, read 19 Nov 2026
UK Money Laundering Regulations 2017, regulation 27 (revised text, up to date to 18 Nov 2026), read 19 Nov 2026
HMRC, Money laundering supervision for art market participants (updated 6 Aug 2024), read 19 Nov 2026
EUR-Lex, Regulation (EU) 2024/1624 (official EU text: Articles 3 and 26, recital 69), read 19 Nov 2026